When the Dodgers traded second baseman Dee Gordon to the Miami Marlins after the 2014 season, they essentially traded away their best leadoff hitter since Rafael Furcal, who held that post from 2006 to 2011. Oh sure, they toyed around with Carl Crawford, Nick Punto, Skip Schumaker, Jerry Hairston Jr., Yasiel Puig, Joc Pederson, Kiké Hernandez and several others, but the cold hard truth is that they haven’t had a real dyed-in-the-wool leadoff hitter in quite some time.
When spring training 2016 began last month, new Dodgers manager Dave Roberts was often asked who he was planning to utilize as his leadoff hitter for the coming season. As politely as he could, Roberts repeatedly said that the role would depend on pitching match-ups. In other words, the extremely popular new skipper had no idea who his leadoff hitter was going to be.
But all of that changed on Wednesday when Roberts penciled soon-to-be 34-year-old outfielder Andre Ethier in the number one spot on his line-up card.
Why?
“He gets on base,” Roberts told reporters on Wednesday morning.
Indeed he does. In fact, heading into Friday’s game against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Salt River Fields, Ethier had a spring training on-base percentage on .500 that included four walks, seven singles, one triple and one home run.
By all appearances Dave Roberts had finally found his leadoff hitter, arguably the most unlikely one of all. In fact, in his 10-year MLB career, Ethier has never led off a game – not once.
Sure enough and right on cue, Ethier promptly laced the first pitch of the game into right field for a leadoff single and came around to score in what would end up being be a four-run first inning for the Dodgers off of Dbacks right-hander Zack Godley.
Although Ethier grounded out to Dbacks Gold Glove first baseman Paul Goldschmidt in his second at-bat in the second inning, it was his third at-bat in the top of the fourth inning that caused quite a scare for Roberts, all of Ethier’s teammates and every Dodger fan on the planet.
On a 2-0 count, Ethier fouled an 86-MPH Godley cut fastball off of his right leg just below the knee. Not only did Ethier go down, he stayed down for quite some time, eventually bringing out a trainer and Roberts. After several minutes Ethier finally stood back up and to the surprise of everyone resumed his at-bat, drawing a walk. But as he made his way to first base, it was very apparent that he was not okay and was immediately replaced with a pinch runner. A short while later he was taken by cart to the Dodgers clubhouse for X-rays.
“I’m hopeful there’s no fracture,” Roberts told reports immediately follow the game. He added that he is “thinking positive thoughts.”
Those positive thoughts apparently worked as late Friday evening word spread that the X-rays had come back negative and that the veteran outfield (and apparent new Dodgers leadoff hitter) is listed as “day to day” with a lower leg contusion.
Although this is great news, the phrase day to day is rather ambiguous. How often have we seen day to day turn into week to week and occasionally even month to month. And while this is certainly not to suggest that Ethier’s contusion is more serious than what we’re being told, you most certainly can expect Roberts to error on the side of caution when it comes to writing Ethier’s name at the top of his lineup card. Keep in mind that it was a June 8, 2015 foul ball off the left knee of Dodgers third baseman Justin Turner that led to problems for the remainder of the season for the popular redhead and eventual led to off-season microfracture surgery.
That being said, it certainly won’t hurt if Dodger fans do what Roberts did…
“Thinking positive thoughts.”
Note: Ethier entered the clubhouse this morning on crutches – but they were ‘Day to Day’ crutches. 😉
The dreaded “day-to-day” prognosis. At least they didn’t say a “strained” something or other.
Probably could learn from hockey. Players get “upper body injuries” or “lower body injuries” that cover a multitude of sins.
Got love day-to-day since you never know when the first day is.
I can’t help but think the same way you are, on this one, Ron.
I reckon it’s another “wait and see” situation. There are a few positive points:
There’s over 2 weeks ’til opening day.
Carl Crawford appears healthy. I was gonna add (for now) but this is s’posed to be positive.
Scott Van Slyke is hitting like he has a grudge against baseballs.
They have Kike (positive thinking extends to Corey) and some decent minor league options.
I’m starting to think that Roberts needs to insert himself in the lineup. There is just no lead off hitter on this team.
I really like a speedster at the top of the line up. However, if Andre has a good OBP, I guess that is the best they can do, which isn’t bad but no SB potential.
I do think the team is running better already – more alertly and taking the extra base.
“I do think the team is running better already – more alertly and taking the extra base.” Credit Doc for that, but I suspect Maury has something to do with it too. I haven’t heard anything since ST started, but I really doubt he’s spending his days napping.
Andre isn’t your prototypical leadoff guy, this much is certain… and he won’t be leading the league in stolen bases either. But the one thing he does have is a solid understanding of fundamental base-running skills. Top that off with his above average first-to-third speed, and Ethier scores on most balls hit in the gaps. Here’s to hoping that “day-to-day” really means just that.
This injury obviously bumps up Carl Crawford’s playing time. However, Andre’s earned the position and has been the most consistent outfielder on the team.
Who will be the next “pure” leadoff man to don a Dodgers jersey?
Rico Noel… if they can find a roster spot for him.