Dodgers right-handed reliever Ryan Madson did something that every Dodger player only dreams of doing in the World Series, he is now 7-for-7. The problem is, his 7-for-7 has absolutely nothing to do with hitting, but rather having all seven of the runners that he has inherited in his combined 2.1 innings pitched through the first four games of the soon to be completed 2018 Fall Classic to score; and when you think about it, that’s a pretty amazing.
…not good, but amazing nonetheless.
The upside is that when you look at Madson’s stats from the series, he has allowed only one run, earned or otherwise, himself. Unfortunately for the Dodgers and Dodger fans, it came as a result of a three-run home run in the seventh inning of Saturday night’s painful backbreaking (and spirit-breaking) 9-6 loss in Game-4 of the best-of-seven series which, barring an absolute miracle or some divine intervention, will probably be over in less than seven games.
Madson, whom the Dodgers acquired at the August 31 waiver trade deadline from the Washington Nationals for 26-year-old right-handed pitching prospect Andrew Istler, was brought on board specifically with the postseason in mind, with the 36-year-old Long Beach, California native and 1998 ninth-round draft pick by the Philadelphia Phillies, having appeared in (now) 57 postseason games over 16 different postseason series.
Amazingly, Madson has a very respectable 6-1 career postseason record with an equally amazing 2.73 ERA over his (now) combined 56.0 postseason innings pitched. But here again, when you allow inherited baserunners to score, they do not appear on your résumé, but are charged to the guy who put them on base.
On Saturday night, that guy was Dodgers left-hander Scott Alexander, who was a last-minute addition the Dodgers manager Dave Roberts’ World Series team, replacing far more popular 22-year-old left-hander Caleb Ferguson, who has pretty much been lights out since his June 6 call-up, initially as a starter but later as long reliever.
By virtue of a seventh-inning leadoff walk issued by Dodgers left-handed starter Rich Hill, who was absolutely brilliant of his 6.1 innings of work having allowed no runs and only one hit to the best offense in all of baseball, to Red Sox shortstop Xander Bogaerts, followed immediately by a three-pitch strikeout of the always dangerous Edwardo Nunez, Roberts pulled Hill for Alexander with one out and Bogaerts on first base. Alexander, a supposed ground ball / double play expert, promptly walked Red Sox second baseman Brock Holt … on four pitches.
After facing that one and only batter, Alexander was replaced by Madson who, after getting Red Sox pinch-hitter Jackie Bradley Jr. to pop out to second, threw a first-pitch absolute meatball 85.4 mph change-up to Red Sox pinch-hitter Mitch Moreland.
Big mistake.
In the blink of an eye, Hill’s outstanding 6.1 innings of one-hit ball turned a 4-0 shutout into a 4-3 ballgame. The Red Sox would add another six runs to their tally, while the Dodgers added but one in their eventual embarrassing 9-6 loss, to give the Red Sox a three games to one lead in the series.
Why on earth would Roberts pull Hill when he was absolutely cruising and had Boston in complete check, you ask? Here was his explanation:
“[Hill] said, ‘Keep an eye on me, I’m going to give it everything I have, [but] let’s go hitter to hitter and just keep an eye on me,'” Roberts told reporters after the game. “So right there, I know Rich did everything he could, competed, left everything out there.”
Even at face value, there is nothing in Hill’s comment that suggests that he was done. He was merely (and professionally) letting his manager know that he did not know how much longer he could go. Heck, even President Donald Trump could see this:
To their credit, even though the Dodgers are now on the brink of losing their second consecutive World Series, some Dodger fans maintained their good sense of humor:
As he has done throughout the World Series, rather than simply acknowledge that he screwed up, Roberts yet again tried to justify his unjustifiable decision by refusing to look beyond the analytics and sabermetrics guidelines that undoubtedly came from above.
“In that spot right there, considering who you have left in the ‘pen, you have to make a decision,” said Roberts. “And I felt that Ryan still had a very good chance to get him out.”
The Red Sox thank you, Doc.
Dodger fans? Not so much.
We can now almost always expect a Dodger starting pitcher to be taken out after 5 or 6 innings no matter how well he’s pitching. It sure looked good leading 4-0 going into the 7th inning but I guess it was too good to be true. Losing is one thing but HOW they lost really hurt.
Y’think Mr. Trump might want to give up his day job to manage the Dodgers?
The thrill of victory and the agony of defeat!
Last nights game is the perfect example of the above and “snatching defeat from the jaws of victory”.
You are right Ron, “I can pretty much assure you that it was actually the opinion of every Dodger fan on the planet” that pulling Hill was a mistake. I know at my house all eight of us watching the game were of that opinion.
Hill was dealing, 6.1 innings of 1 hit ball! He had only thrown 91 pitches, and Roberts should have known the same thing every Dodgers fan knew, he had a tired bullpen. Oh, and apparently Roberts missed what Fox knew, the Red Sox struggled mightily with lefties who throw a lot of breaking balls.
My biggest problem with what Roberts did was replacing Hill with Alexander, a lefty for a lefty. Alexander looked like a deer in the headlights Friday and he obviously wasn’t ready to compete yesterday either. A four pitch walk is inexcusable. Madson looks bad now, but he was the most rested guy in the bullpen.
Jansen pretty much matched Madson’s night after throwing 32 pitches Friday and Floro was horrible after throwing 29 pitches Friday.
Yeah, Roberts, et al, got a lesson in bullpen management last night. Our Very Stable Genius President, who was scouted by the Phillies as a young man, could have done a better job last night just like the rest of us.
Just like my fellow Dodgers fan since the 1950s keeps telling me……”one way or the other they will break your heart.”
For what its worth, for my money Ferguson should have been on the roster and NOT Alexander.
The bullpen is making the offseason non-tender decisions easy for F & Z.
Decisions,decisions,decisions that is the question. Going to be an interesting offseason.
Even after another disappointing end, the state of the Dodgers is good. Lots to work with going forward.
1. Young core
2. Good farm
3. At least two young starter studs. Maybe more.
4. Improving financial flexibility
5. Lots of trade assets
Let’s win a seventh straight division title in 2019, go back to the series where the third time is a charm.
what happened to organist dieter ruehle tonight?
Not exactly sure what you mean.
I watched the games aired on fox from dodger stadium, and the first 2 had organist ruehle playing the organ, however the organ in the third game seemed to be played in a different manor, Living our entire lives in NYC, we aren’t Red Sock fans, but all in all this season they were unbeatable as well as unbearable.
They mentioned near the beginning of the broadcast that he was there.