The Dodgers made it to game-7 of the 2007 World Series by winning an MLB-best 104 games during the regular season, three games in the National League Division Series, four games in the National League Championship Series and three of the first six games of the World Series. That’s a remarkable 114 wins.
But the Dodgers lost the 2007 World Series on exactly 47 pitches made by Dodgers right-hander Yu Darvish, the same guy that the team – and an entire nation – rallied behind after being the victim of racism by Houston Astros first baseman Yuli Gurriel, this in addition to also losing game-3 of the Fall Classic in which he made a total of 80 pitches in only 1.2 innings pitched.
In the simplest of terms, Yu Darvish failed his teammates and millions of Dodger fans on baseball’s grandest stage not once, but twice.
But the saddest part about Wednesday night’s devastating 5-1 loss to the now World Series Champion Houston Astros is that it never should have happened – period.
In addition to his regular bullpen stable of Tony Cingrani, Josh Fields, Kenta Maeda, Brandon McCarthy, Brandon Morrow, Ross Stripling and star closer Kenley Jansen, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts also had starting pitchers Clayton Kershaw and Alex Wood available to him for the single most important game of the 2017 season; the one game that was the difference in being the champions of the baseball world or being the soon-to-be forgotten World Series runners-up.
Quick … name the team that lost the 2005 World Series without looking it up.
See what I mean?
There is no one, not one person on the planet, who had a problem with Darvish starting game-7. Hey, anyone can have a bad day like the one that Darvish had five days earlier in game-3 at Minute Maid Park in Houston, right? But with all of the greatness that Roberts literally had at his finger tips (via a direct phone to the Dodgers bullpen), there is no way on God’s green earth that Darvish ever should have been allowed to continue after giving up his second of what would soon become five Astros runs. In doing so, it is impossible to not think of the old saying: “Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.”
Shame on you, Dave Roberts.
Granted, you can argue that only four of the five runs allowed by the 31-year-old Habikino, Japan in game-7 were earned, or even that two runs would have been enough to beat the Dodgers on Wednesday night before a sold out Dodger Stadium crowd of 54,124. But when Darvish allowed his fifth (and final) run on a two-run home run by eventual World Series MVP George Springer with two outs in the top of the second inning, you could feel the excitement and energy – and any hopes of the Dodgers winning their first World Series title in 29 years – leave Dodger Stadium with Springer’s home run ball.
Although a five-run deficit is/was most certainly not insurmountable by this Dodgers team, it is/was a lot more difficult to overcome than a two-run deficit would have been which, here again, absolutely should have been the length of Darvish’s leash under any circumstances with the weapons that Roberts had at his disposal a mere 350 feet down the left field line in the Dodgers bullpen.
After allowing a completely ineffective Darvish to give up five runs, Roberts finally removed him after 1.2 innings which, coincidentally, was the exact same number of ineffective innings that he lasted in his game-3 start five days earlier. It was blatantly obvious that the second-year Dodgers manager was hoping (against all hope) that Darvish would finish the painful second inning down only 2-0 so that he could pinch-hit for Darvish in the bottom half of the second inning, with Darvish’s spot due up third.
Instead, Darvish left a 98.2-MPH four-seam fastball right over the middle of the plate that Springer absolutely crushed, sending it 438 feet into the Left Field Pavilion of Dodger Stadium for a back-breaking two-run home run that essentially ended the Dodgers 2017 season. It was a classic example of over-managing, something that the defending 2016 NL Manager of the Year has rarely done in his two seasons as the Dodgers skipper.
After Springer’s devastating blast, Roberts finally brought in hard-throwing right-hander Brandon Morrow to get out of the inning without further damage, which he did by striking out Astros left fielder Marwin Gonzalez on three pitches. But unfortunately for Roberts, the Dodgers, and all of their fans, the irreparable damage had been done.
In his two World Series starts, Darvish lasted a combined 3.1 innings, allowed a combined nine runs (eight earned) on nine hits including two home runs, while walking two and striking out zero. There is bad, and then there is Yu Darvish bad.
Over the next seven innings, Messrs. Kershaw, Jansen and Wood allowed no runs and only two hits (off of Kershaw) with a combined three walks (two intentional) and nine strikeouts. In other words, Roberts decision to utilize starters Clayton Kershaw and Alex Wood in addition to relievers Brandon Morrow and Kenley Jansen worked flawlessly and exactly as planned. Unfortunately, Darvish had already spotted the Astros five runs to put the Dodgers into a hole from which they could not escape … although the Dodgers most certainly had their chances. They were an inexcusable 1-for-13 with runners in scoring position and left a total of 10 runners on base on the night.
The lone bright spot for the Dodgers in Wednesday’s World Series finale was a pinch-hit single by Dodgers senior statesman Andre Ethier that allowed Joc Pederson to score from second base. That was the sum, mass and total of the Dodgers offense in the single most important game for every man on the Dodgers roster.
In a gracious and noble attempt to offer up an apology (of sorts) to Dodger fans, Darvish posted this on Twitter shortly after Wednesday night’s painful loss:
Although there is no disputing Darvish’s sincerity, the timing of his statement (apology?) on social media is a bit suspect. As most Dodger fans know, the 6′-5″ / 220-pound right-hander became a free agent when the final out was recorded on Wednesday night, thus bringing an end to his six-year / $56 million contract. In other words, his (perhaps) ill-time statement might be perceived by many as a plea to Dodgers to seriously consider re-signing him to what would undoubtedly be a very significant salary increase. There is a very good chance that this is the very last thing that bruised Dodger fans want to even think about right now, if you get my drift.
But alas here we are, Day-1 of the remaining 147 days until Opening Day 2018 on Thursday, March 29, when the 2017 World Series runners up – who all but Dodger fans will soon forget – will square off against another orange-wearing team – the perennially-hated San Francisco Giants – at Dodger Stadium. But for as painfully long as that is, I absolutely cannot wait for it!
Is it time for Dodger baseball yet?
* * * * * * * *
By the way, the team that lost the 2005 World Series was the Houston Astros.
As much as Darvish cost us the series, (and there’s no doubt he did). I can’t help but be amazed that the team lasted 7 games with the inept offensive performances of Turner, Bellinger, Puig, Seager, Barnes and others. Sure they had their moments, but when the ballclub hits a combined .205 with a .290 OBP, it’s tough to win.
Roberts’ long leash with Darvish was inexplicable. Just as his short leash with Hill was. There were dozens of questionable decisions made by Dave Roberts, so many that I have serious reservations about his managerial abilities. That questionable bunt with Kike, using up the pitching staff for one batter at times, sticking with Bellinger in the clean up spot when he was obviously overmatched, Morrow’s overuse, these are just a few that I can think of off the top of my head.
The series can be picked apart, game by game. Reality is the Dodgers had this series in their grasp, but they were outplayed by Houston, a more deserving winner. We can complain about Bill Miller’s atrocious strike zone in game five for a while, and it’ll stick in my craw, that’s for sure. But deep down, I think it simply wasn’t in the cards that we’d win it.
This was an exciting series, one of the greatest in memory. I tend to disagree when you say that the runner-up won’t be remembered. Games 2 and 5 will allow the 2017 Dodgers to be remembered as the 86 Red Sox were remembered…heartbreaking losers. Probably it would be best to not be remembered at all because I have a feeling that those games will be replayed on MLB network for years to come.
Thanks for your work Ron. I know that wasn’t an easy piece to write.
Some additional comments:
Final stats from the 7 games
Runs scored: Houston: 34, Los Angeles 34
ERA: Houston 4.64, Los Angeles 4.45
Team Batting Average: Houston .230, Los Angeles .205
Team On Base %: Houston .297, Los Angeles .290
The differences are statistically insignificant. We essentially played a 176 game season to a virtual tie. It hurts to not walk away with the title, but either team could have been justifiably crowned the world champion.
It is very painful to not come out on top, but the Dodgers had an AMAZING year. Arguably their best in franchise history.
No question about it that Roberts’ leaving Darvish in to start inning two or especially to pitch to Springer was a mystery with so many options available.
As to losing the series, I agree with Evan that the Dodgers got outplayed, albeit by just enough to hand Houston the title. Miraculously they forced a game 7.
I still can’t get past Kenley and Clayton blowing games that all season long were sure fired victories. With their usual performances, the Dodgers would have won before game seven.
One of the things that really bothered before game-7 on Wednesday were the countless people talking about the parade that was scheduled for Friday morning and how it was going to end at Dodger Stadium, where a sold-out crowd was expected. When I would say “That’s if the Dodgers win tonight,” knowing full well that the Astros weren’t going to just hand the trophy to the Dodgers.
The looks that I got from these people were amazing. They absolutely believed that after the game-6 win, the Astros were just going to concede game-7 to them.
I could tell within the first two minutes of the game that the game-3 Darvish was back and that the Dodgers were in deep s***. That said, I NEVER expected a complete top to bottom meltdown by the Dodgers offense. Going 1-for-13 w/ RISP was something that the 64-win Giants would do, most certainly not the 104-win Dodgers.
It was unquestionably the most brokenhearted I have even been in my 63 years as a Dodger fan, but at least I have this:
BTW – If you think being the runners up in the World Series is ok, here’s what Clayton Kershaw thinks about it:
“It’s too hard to think about what the Astros are getting to do right now. It’s too hard to think about all that.”
It is not OK after 29 years but I expect 28 other teams would liked to have at least been there.
I know it is blasphemy to point a finger at Clayton but in five significant post season games against the Phillies, Cards(2), Cubs and Astros he has given up 31 earned runs in 26.2 innings. He set a post season record for home runs allowed.
As mentioned before the WS started, someone had to step up and be dominant. That is, be a Podres, Burdette, Lolich, Koufax, Gibson, Hershiser, Bumgartner. I expected Clayton to do that. No doubt he expected that of himself. At some point he will have to learn to dominate in pressure post season/WS situations.
I certainly am not solely blaming Clayton for the loss, just expressing my disappointment which no doubt pales in comparison to his.
That would make a great article, Harold.
I first want to say I’m very sad, we didn’t win. Actually sadder than I thought I’d be, but I can’t help think about what this team accomplished.
Along with winning it’s 5th consecutive NL West Title, it won the pennant for the first time in 29 years. Although some don’t make a big thing about it, these days and most non-Dodger fans will forget about it, none of us, Dodger fans, will ever forget that the Dodgers were the 2017 National League Champions. With the biggest payroll in baseball, I can’t help to see an awfully bright future.
Like they use to say when I was a kid, “Wait ’til next year”.
Winning the pennant but not the World Series is like kissing your sister.
IT. Means. Nothing.
If you don’t think so, look again at what Kershaw had to say about it.
That being said, the 2017 World Series was, by far, the most exciting of my life.