New ‘Utley Rule’ a done deal

Major League Baseball (MLB) and the Major League Baseball Players Association (MLBPA) have announced two significant rule changes which will go into effect immediately.

As anticipated, MLB and the MLBPA have adopted a new sliding rule in the wake of the now infamous takeout slide by Dodgers second baseman Chase Utley that left Mets shortstop Ruben Tejada with a fractured right fibula during Game-2 of the 2015 NLDS.

Even though Utley's slide was technically within the existing rules. at the time, it was unquestionably late and a big reason why MLB and the MLBPA have enacted a new sliding rule change. (Video capture courtesy of TBS - Click on image to view video)

Even though Utley’s slide was technically within the existing rules at the time, it was unquestionably late and a big reason why MLB and the MLBPA enacted a new sliding rule.
(Video capture courtesy of TBS – Click on image to view video)

Rule, 6.01(j), reads as follows:

RULE 6.01(j) — SLIDING TO BASES ON DOUBLE PLAY ATTEMPTS

If a runner does not engage in a bona fide slide, and initiates (or attempts to make) contact with the fielder for the purpose of breaking up a double play, he should be called for interference under this Rule 6.01. A “bona fide slide” for purposes of Rule 6.01 occurs when the runner:

(1) begins his slide (i.e., makes contact with the ground) before reaching the base;

(2) is able and attempts to reach the base with his hand or foot;

(3) is able and attempts to remain on the base (except home plate) after completion of the slide; and

(4) slides within reach of the base without changing his pathway for the purpose of initiating contact with a fielder.

According to the interpretation of the new rule, any violation of rule 6.01(j) will result in an automatic double play being called by the umpires.

In addition to 6.01(j), MLB and the MLBPA have also agreed to now make so-called “neighborhood plays” reviewable. The theory behind this expansion of video review is that since the base runner can no longer takeout the shortstop or second baseman in an attempt to breakup a double play (although technically they still can if their slide is “bona fide”), the shortstop or second baseman will no longer be given a “close enough” exemption and must actually touch the bag. And while the intent of this video review expansion is valid, not everyone agrees with it.

“We’re making a slide rule that keeps you on the bag,” said Mets manager Terry Collins after being informed of the elimination of the neighborhood play. “You’ve got to be near the bag. And now we’re making a decision on the neighborhood play that you’ve got to stay on the bag. You know what that’s going to mean? Someone is going to get their clocks cleaned.”

But the simple truth is that adopting the takeout slide rule (which will undoubtedly forever be called the Utley Rule) and the (technical) elimination of the neighborhood play are both long overdue, this in spite of the longstanding argument that both are traditional parts of our 147-year-old national pastime. And while there may be some merit to the argument that an experienced shortstop or second baseman at baseball’s highest level should know how to effectively get out of the way while making a double play, awkward throws (etc.) sometimes put them in a dangerous position. And when teams are investing millions of dollars for their middle infielders these day, Rule 6.01(j) is designed to protect their investments, let alone extending baseball careers.

MLB and the MLBPA also agreed to further improve the “pace of play” by reducing the between-inning time from 2:25 minutes to 2:05 minutes (2:25 for nationally televised games) and now limiting mound visits by pitching coaches and managers to 30 seconds from the time that they exit the dugout until they turn to walk off the mound. The obvious intent of this new pace of play guideline is to prevent coaches and managers from purposely delaying the game to allow relievers additional time to warm up in the bullpen. And although there was no mention of what the penalty will be for violating this new pace of play guideline, it will probably be similar to the batters box rule where a reminder will be given by umpires, followed by a letter from MLB, followed by an undisclosed fine.

Although there will undoubtedly be those who are upset that these new rule changes are being implemented only 38 days before Opening Day, each of the 30 teams will have the exact same amount of time to work these changes into their game during spring training.

 

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

11 Responses to “New ‘Utley Rule’ a done deal”

  1. Respect the Rivalry says:

    I still think my suggestion from awhile back is simpler, and better:
    On a force play the runner must slide directly to the base. The fielder with the ball must tag the base (that’s already the rule).

    • Badger3 says:

      The rule is already in the book 7:09d:.any runner who has just been put out hinders or impedes any following play being made on another runner. Batter runner is out because of the action of his teammate. Ball is dead. No runs may score.7:09e and f also deal with deliberate intent to break up a double play. I think it’s clear when you read them.

      These rules have been on the books for decades. They were there when I umped in the 70’s. I used to tell the guys “get down or get out of the way. Slide in the baseline and don’t slide past the bag.” Call it once and you don’t see it again.

      • Respect the Rivalry says:

        That still left a grey area. MLB’s interpretation: If the runner begins his slide before being put out he’s allowed to follow through on his motion (common sense) and he must be able to reach the base.
        Just directing sliding directly to the base on a force play eliminates any bogus interpretation.
        BTW, “to the base” means exactly that. Oversliding the base is sliding to a point past the base. It isn’t hard to stop at the base when sliding directly to it since it sticks up.

  2. OldBrooklynFan says:

    Am I right in assuming that the new ruling basic eliminates the neighborhood play?

  3. Snider Fan says:

    The concern over the pace of play is laughable when it takes at least five minutes to review plays. And do you think the fact that Joe Torre’s brother got hurt in a takeout slide in the 1959 playoff might have something to do with the new rule, or the fact that the Dodgers’ chances of winning an appeal to New York is less than 1 in 10?

    • Ron Cervenka says:

      These changes were agreed upon by the players association as well at the MLB. Just sayin.

    • Respect the Rivalry says:

      I believe the average time for a review is something like 2-3 minutes. That’s less than the average time for an argument.
      Maybe somebody here has the actual figure.

  4. Respect the Rivalry says:

    I just got to thinking: The only time I saw the neighborhood play not allowed last year was a Dodgers game. The umpire said he doesn’t allow the neighborhood play. The part that didn’t fit was this was a late season game and apparently this issue with him hadn’t come up before.
    While I did agree with his view of the neighborhood play, I don’t think maverick umpires are such a good idea. Right or wrong, the players need to know what rules they’re playing by.
    Incidentally, the fielder’s left foot was on the dirt to the first base side of second. I couldn’t really say for sure from watching the replay, but it appeared the side of his foot may have been against the side of the base. If so the runners out anyway. It wasn’t reviewed of course, since it was called a neighborhood play.
    Here’s the irony. The infielder was Chase Utley.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress