We all know that spring training games are meaningless, right? I mean, isn’t that what players, coaches and managers always say after losing a spring training game? It’s kind of interesting that you never seem to hear players, coaches and managers that win spring training games say this – kind of like you never hear winning players, coaches or managers say “it’s still early” in April and May as you do from losing players, coaches or managers trying to justify their loss.
I’m sorry but I disagree – spring training games are not meaningless games, especially if you are a scout or even more so if you are a general manager who may one day have to make a decision on which player to keep and which player to trade. And if you were a scout or GM, who would you rather choose to go after or choose to keep – the guy who runs out every play as fast as his God-given talent allows him to (and who frequently beats out throws by doing so), of the guy who “phones it in” and lollygags back to first base on a routine fly ball out to right field and gets doubled up by a good two feet because of it, whereas he could have easily made it back if he had run at even half speed?
I am, of course, comparing phenom prospect Yasiel Puig with 7-year MLB veteran (and owner of a 5-year/$85 million contract) Andre Ethier, who made a complete ass out of himself for doing the latter in the Dodgers 5-3 loss to the Diamondbacks on Monday afternoon at Camelback Ranch.
Ethier being doubled up at first base because of his lack of hustle was disgusting, spring training game or otherwise. Even Little Leaguers know better than this. It was a joke. Is Andre such a prima donna that he would think that the right fielder wouldn’t dare try to double him up off of first base because it’s only a spring training game? Ya, right. What kind of message does Ethier’s “meh” attitude send to the thousands of kids who worship the ground that he walks on?
I can only hope that Dodgers first base coach Davey Lopes gave Andre an well-deserved ass chewing (and I have to believe that he did) for his bush-league attitude.
Did Ethier’s embarrassing play affect the outcome of the game? Maybe not. But maybe it did. One thing is for certain – it brought an abrupt end to a one-out rally.
Please don’t get me wrong, I am a huge Andre Ethier fan – especially over the past several years during which time he has clearly matured and has become a team leader and a much-needed veteran presence in the Dodger clubhouse. But here again, what message did Ethier’s actions send to the many minor leaguers who were in the dugout at the time of his screw up, not to mention to the 10,332 fans in attendance.
We still love you, Dre, but please play the game the right way, even in these so-called meaningless games – because they aren’t meaningless to us and probably not to Ned Colletti either.
Didn’t see the play but from what I hear about it Andre messed up royally. That being said I agree to a point with your opinion on spring training games. In the beginning of ST I’d say no to the balls out on everything stuff, that’s how injuries happen and the players are not in good enough shape to do it without risking injury. Mid way through ST and especially by the end of ST I totally agree, they need to be playing at mid season form !!
Spring training games are not meaningless. They are more than conditioning IMO. Teams are gearing up for the season and much is to be gained in ST – team building, winning attitude, playing hard attitude.
Players are scrapping for a spot on the MLB team or at the higher levels in the minors. Others are working to impress so that they may be traded to teams with spots they could fill. Still others have opt out clauses and are working hard to succeed and become free agents with the hopes of catching on with another team. All are trying to impress.
ST is a time to make mistakes so they are not replicated during the regular season. Andre’s mistake yesterday should not have happened. I’m guessing he will not repeat it. The embarrassment itself is enough to keep his mind in the game for the rest of the year. Puig’s base running error today (not hustling out of the box) cost him an easy double and hitting for the cycle. Fortunately it did not cost a game. ST is the time to learn that.
Colletti said it best yesterday; (to paraphrase) Lots of wins in the Spring gives the impression your team is better than they are, and just the opposite with a lot of Spring losses, feeling your team is worse off than they really are.
Speaking about Puig and Spring Training in general, Colletti said:
“Spring is to set an impression to get a feel for who’s who — who you may be able to count on as the season goes on, and what they need to work on between now and the time we’re gonna need him. I think he needs to play on an everyday basis to see what a season feels like.”